A Greek Tragedy Awaits The Proud

What do financial columnists, ancient Greek dramatists and modern psychologists have in common?   Each deal with “Hubris” – excessive pride, arrogance and or overconfidence.

The plot lines of many Greek plays rely on hubris.  Hubris followed by nemesis. Punishment from the gods, being the common form. 

Psychologists deal regularly with various expressions of hubris.  From narcissism to the Icarus complex.  From ascensionism to perpetual adolesence.

Financial columnists are more interesting still.  Many, while perhaps not subject to hubris in themselves, are carriers.  They present ideas that are so oversimplified that they are meaningless, but they convince the unaware that the implied behaviour is possible.  For example, if someone pays a 2% fee to a financial advisor, over the course of 30 years they will have given away X% of their potential accumulation.  All true and a large share, too. 

That idea seeds hubris in readers.  People assume that if they lose 30% of their money because of the fees, then they can keep that money if they use the do-it-yourself approach.  Do-it-yourself can work, but like Icarus you must know the conditions under which it will work and avoid exceeding those limits.

Here is the short story.  If you want to do it yourself, you must somehow replace what the advisor did before you decided they were too costly.

The easier and columnist implied option is for you to decide that what advisors do is valueless.  Hubris squared.  New word to apply “floccinaucinihilipilification”  – The act or habit of describing or regarding something as unimportant, of having no value or being worthless.

To set out to do something like retirement planning on your own assumes that you think you know all you need to know to be successful.  Unless you know what the advisor did and have the time and skill to replace it, do-it-yourself is Hubris.  Overconfidence, excessive pride, arrogance.

The ancient Greek gods may be unconcerned about what goes on outside Greece, and so their retributive justice may be avoided.  Nemesis however is a natural construct.  Even though the gods may not deliver it, punishment will nonetheless appear.

Overconfidence in one’s ability is financially lethal yet you see it every day.  People try things where they have not the slightest reasonable expectation of success.  Everyone who can barbecue a hamburger can run a restaurant.  Everyone who owns a hammer and saw is a carpenter.  Every tradesman can be a contractor.  Every line worker can be an executive.  Everyone with money can be a financial advisor. 

Before setting out on the road to easy wealth, find out what financial advisors actually do.  You can then make an objective assessment of the costs and benefits.  To assume you know everything, have access to everything you will need, and can carry it all out with diligence and without emotion, is hubris.

Be sure to include a defence against nemesis in your plan.

Contact: don@moneyfyi.com  

Don Shaughnessy is a retired partner in an international public accounting firm and is now with The Protectors Group, a large personal insurance, employee benefits and investment agency in Peterborough Ontario.

This entry was posted in Decision Making, Personal Finance, Planning and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Greek Tragedy Awaits The Proud

  1. Brian says:

    In my many years of sales management, I have, if nothing else, become something of a connoisseur of hubris. And the child of hubris, irrational behavior. The two commonalities I have noticed between high achievers, neurotics, manipulators and downright sociopaths, is their non-negotiable and myopic narcisism, and their pervasive, insatiable unhappiness. I have come to view the latter as the product of the former.
    The good news is that I occasionally have come upon individuals who have managed to wring happiness and productivity out of less than ideal circumstances, and with less than optimal personal resources. These people seem to have, through design or management, avoided taking themselves too seriously, and have avoided the endless comparisons that haunt many “driven” people. Comparison is truly the thief of joy.
    Life isn’t a game, it’s your life. It’s not numbers on a piece of paper, it’s the sum of what you have done in your finite hours of consciousness. It can be bigger than you, if you dare, or it can be a minute footnote, if you hoard it. There are no trial runs, and when it’s over, the sum of your existence will not be measured by what you consider important. It will be measured by what you have put into the lives of others around you, and how important it is to them.

  2. Pingback: A Wise Response To Hubris | moneyFYI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s